Of all the marlin stocks currently assessed, white marlin are perhaps in the worst shape. For the past three decades or so, they’ve been severely overfished and, until 2011, were said to be experiencing overfishing. The International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas has recorded the white marlin catch since 1956: Early on, total catches were minimal, but in 1965, those catches peaked at 5,000 tons. ICCAT has since capped the total white marlin catch at 400 tons for the entire Atlantic after the last ICCAT assessment for white marlin that was conducted in 2011.
However, there is significant skepticism whether current management measures are adequate to rebuild the white marlin stock. The next stock assessment for white marlin is slated for 2018, so we’ll have to wait a year to see whether things are improving.
That’s the science side of things for the entire Atlantic. However, if you talk to recreational anglers along the mid-Atlantic, they’ll probably tell you the white marlin fishing has been great for a while now and it’s only getting better. So how does one reconcile the seemingly disparate observations of the ICCAT scientific community and U.S. recreational anglers? Well, the National Marine Fisheries Service has actually aggressively managed billfish within federal waters for the past three decades. Some of the more-significant management measures have included:
• 1988: Prohibition on commercial harvest or sale of Atlantic billfish
• 1998: Size limits instituted for blue and white marlin
• 2000: Time/area closures to the Atlantic pelagic longline fleet
• 2000s-present: Increased voluntary use of circle hooks by recreational anglers, with mandatory use in billfish tournaments in 2007
• 2001: Recreational harvest capped at 250 white/blue marlin
• 2004: Required the Atlantic PLL fleet to use circle hooks